Return to Amish star Rosanna Miller‘s bikini appearance left fans with a lot of questions as production must have made a slip-up. Rosanna and Maureen Byler go swimsuit shopping. But, it seems like it may not have been their first time going.
Return to Amish: Rosanna Miller & Maureen Byler Go Shopping
On Return to Amish, newcomers Rosanna Miller and Maureen Byler are ready to hit the beach. But, before they can soak up the sun, they have to get beach attire. Being Amish, they aren’t allowed to wear swimsuits or even show off their skin. However, Rosanna and Maureen want to ditch their Amish ways. So, they go with Ada to go bathing suit shopping for the first time.
The Return to Amish reality stars were nervous and excited to try on swimsuits. However, Rosanna Miller and Maureen Byler didn’t find shopping for beachwear easy. So, they had a sales associate help them. When asked what size they are, Maureen and Rosanna didn’t know how to answer since all their clothes are made for them.
According to Maureen, the only clothing Amish buy from an English store is panties. Ada had suggested they go with that size.
Viewers Notice Rosanna’s Tan Lines
Rosanna Miller and Maureen Byler tried on a few different styles. However, the Return to Amish castmates felt uncomfortable showing off so much skin. But, they eventually found ones that they liked. Maureen stuck to buying a one-piece. She said she didn’t want to show off her “goods” just yet. On the other hand, Rosanna went out of her comfort zone and bought a two-piece.
While trying on swimsuits, something about Rosanna Miller caught Return to Amish viewers’ attention. People noticed that she had tan lines. If this was Rosanna’s first time wearing a bikini, she should not already have tan lines. Some people are calling out the editing for trying to trick them.
Return to Amish Fans Question Production
Many Return to Amish viewers believe that TLC is lying about Rosanna Miller’s story. One person said that they’re “pretty sure she’s not even Amish while filming.” Another person said that it looks like Rosanna had already “hit up the beach” before the season. A person even claimed that Rosanna and her friend, Maureen Byler, had allegedly left the Amish a long time ago.
On the other hand, some Return to Amish fans have doubts that the production is real. One person said that the “friendship with the salesgirl wasn’t organic” and felt fake. Another person thought that the scene where Rosanna Miller and Maureen Byler cleaned a lady’s house was “so overproduced.” A person also said that it is the “most scripted reality show” they have ever seen.
However, one fan came to the network’s defense. They said that the production crew could have filmed that scene before, but it didn’t work out, so they re-shot it later on. That would explain the tan lines. Was it a production error – or is the storyline a setup?
Stay up-to date on all the latest Return to Amish here at Soap Dirt.