‘Return to Amish’: Jeremiah Raber Plays Matchmaker for Ada?
Jeremiah Raber finds himself playing matchmaker for Ada Byler on Return to Amish. He was looking to build a relationship with Dennis. But it seems like someone else may be doing the same.
Return to Amish: Ada Byler Leaves Community after Cheating Scandal
Ada Byler lives life on her terms. The Return to Amish reality star has broken a few rules that go against her strict community. However, her behavior isn’t the only reason her community is turning its back on her.
Sparks are flying between Ada and Dennis on #ReturnToAmish, Tuesdays at 10/9c. pic.twitter.com/HM0OdUCLyu
— TLC Network (@TLC) April 10, 2023
However, Ada did come clean about why her community shunned her. According to the TLC star, her husband had cheated on her. The community put the blame for his infidelity on her.
They told her to be a “better wife.” So, she ended up leaving him and the community. Jeremiah Raber knew about the cheating scandal. But didn’t know if it was true.
According to reports, Ada has moved on from her cheating husband. The Return to Amish celeb was with someone new. This mystery man is even said to be her fiancé. But, despite knowing this man for a few years, she gets flirty with a man Jeremiah thought was his father.
Jeremiah Raber Introduces Ada to Dennis
Jeremiah Raber was on the hunt to find his biological father. He thought a man named Dennis was the man. But a DNA test proved that he wasn’t.
However, Jeremiah eventually finds out who his father is. Yet, he got the unfortunate news that the man had passed away. The Return to Amish castmate was told that his mother had an affair with her sister’s husband and got pregnant. Jeremiah’s aunt then killed her husband, who is his father.

It took a toll on Jeremiah, knowing he could be why his father was no longer alive. So, to not miss out on having a father figure in his life, he reaches back out to Dennis and invites him to Florida.
Jeremiah Raber introduces Ada Byler to Dennis. Right away, sparks were flying. Dennis reveals that Ada is his type of lady. He says seeing her clean is a “woman after his own heart.”
Return to Amish Celeb Breaks Rule for Dennis
Ada Byler checks on Dennis as he cleans his motorcycle. He asks her if she’s seen one before. She tells him, “Oh yeah.” She adds that she likes something noisy and “rattles the seat.”
Jeremiah Raber and his wife, Carmela Raber, watch Dennis and Ada interact. Carmela thinks there is chemistry between the two. So, she starts to giggle, thinking about it. However, Jeremiah doesn’t think it’s funny.
Carmela believes that Ada and Dennis have a lot in common. The Return to Amish cast member feels they both like to talk and make little jokes.
Dennis offers to give the TLC star a ride on his motorcycle. She is hesitant at first since it’s breaking an Amish rule. But she says she’s a “rebel” and hops on the back. She lives life to the “beat of my own buggy.”
Ada admits that she has been lonely lately. So, going out on a bike ride with Dennie is “medicine” for her soul. Could there be love in the air?
Catch the top Return to Amish news at Soap Dirt.
