’90 Day Fiance’: Are Corey and Evelin Already Married – Fans Bamboozle By ‘The Other Way’?

90 Day Fiance: The Other Way stars Corey Rathgeber and Evelin Villegas might be already married as new evidence raises a few red flags. Chatter on social media about this TLC couple point to fans feeling a bit bamboozled by this TLC show.

90 Day Fiance: Corey Rathgeber & Evelin Villegas – ‘The Other Way’ Story Doesn’t Add Up?

Did TLC script a story for the couple Corey Rathgeber and his 90 Day Fiance partner, Evelin Villegas, so they fit with the premise of the show? One of the first things viewers noticed was the wedding ring that Corey Rathgeber wears on his finger.

As reported on Soap Dirt, Evelin Villegas and Corey Rathgeber own a business together in Ecuador. The 90 Day Fiance couple have owned it much longer than suggested on The Other Way. On the show, it appears this is a new venture for the couple but it is a very fishy time line.

It looks like Corey and Evelin have owned their business in Ecuador for quite some time. A photo posted to Instagram back in 2016 shows them running the bar that they own.

90 Day Fiance: Corey Rathgeber -  Evelin Villegas - The Other Way

The Other Way: Too Many Inconsistencies?

There have been red flags for viewers from the get-go when Corey and Evelin were first introduced on 90 Day Fiance. The show opens up with the couple living together in a cabin on the Mormon compound where Corey Rathgeber’s family lives. Basically, they live in Corey’s parents’ backyard in a small dwelling.

Some fans say this doesn’t happen in a Mormon family. Without marriage, Evelin wouldn’t be living together with Corey on their family’s property. This felt bit “off” for some of the TLC viewers from the beginning.

If this information is correct, maybe the couple came back to America to visit Corey’s family and film the 90 Day Fiance: The Other Way at the same time. That visit might be what viewers saw as they lived on the parents’ property.

90 Day Fiance: What’s Up with This?

The TLC cast does get money for appearing on this show so maybe Evelin and Corey fudged the timeline for the money. After all, he’s spent a small fortune on Evelin and her family already.

While their story shown on TV fits The Other Way guidelines, maybe the timeline didn’t. So when the show started, maybe the married couple played out the scenes as it once happened. Is TLC telling their story how it happened years back?

The social media chatter suggests this feels too much like a scripted story for Corey and his “fiance” Evelin Villegas on the show. Maybe they’re married and just replaying their life together for the camera on 90 Day Fiance: The Other Way. If so, it’s not the first time TLC took liberties with reality shows.

Count on Soap Dirt to keep you up to date on 90 Day Fiance: The Other Way.