‘When Calls The Heart’: Elizabeth Chooses Man She’s Meant to Be With

When Calls The Heart schoolteacher Elizabeth Thornton (Erin Krakow) finds herself in the middle of an embarrassing situation. Plus, further details from Nathan Grant (Kevin McGarry) about why he came to Hope Valley. Is Elizabeth’s subconscious telling her something she hasn’t yet acknowledged?

When Calls The Heart: Elizabeth Thornton Participates in Risque Party Games

When Calls The Heart’s Elizabeth Thornton attends the bachelorette party for Florence Blakeley (Loretta Walsh). Party games begin with charades once the men join Elizabeth and the rest of the ladies. Soon, the entertainment turns a bit risque. Fiona Miller (Kayla Wallace) just returned from San Francisco, where she got the idea.

The men line up on one side of the room while the women take turns being blindfolded. The object is for the woman to find the man she’s supposed to be with by moving down the line of men, holding only their hands. Florence quickly finds her Ned Yost (Hrothgar Mathews), and Elizabeth Thornton is up next. The men change places once Elizabeth is blindfolded on Hallmark’s When Calls The Heart.

Elizabeth Thornton reaches Nathan first. After several quiet moments holding hands with him, she removes her mask, saying Lucas Bouchard’s (Chris McNally) name. All the attendees of the bachelorette bash on When Calls The Heart is silent as Elizabeth mistakes Nathan’s hands for Lucas’.

When Calls The Heart: Elizabeth Thornton (Erin Krakow) - Nathan Grant (Kevin McGarry)

WCTH: Elizabeth Confronts Nathan

Before the pre-wedding party on When Calls The Heart, Elizabeth Thornton confronts Nathan Grant about the timing of his confession about her husband’s death. Elizabeth wants to know why he took so long to tell her about his connection to Jack Thornton (Daniel Lissing). Nathan reveals he felt guilty. He was supposed to lead the training mission, but Jack went in his place because Nathan got disciplined for something else.

Nathan said he knew Jack had a wife and child, so he felt his duty was to come to Hope Valley to look after them. But then he found himself falling for Elizabeth Thornton on When Calls The Heart. Nathan Grant told her he fell in love with her and he believes love is “always worth fighting for”.

Elizabeth Thornton stared at Nathan, speechless, in the most recent episode of When Calls The Heart. She finally excused herself and left his office without a reply to his declaration. This is not the first time she left him after he said he loved her. Elizabeth ran away after the first time he told her when they met by the water along the road to Hope Valley on WCTH. Hearties wonder if her inability to respond means her feelings for Nathan Grant run deep.

When Calls The Heart: Lucas Bouchard (Chris McNally)

When Calls The Heart: Lucas is Amused by Her Mistake

Lucas Bouchard, the other man vying for Elizabeth Thornton’s affections on When Calls The Heart, was standing next to Nathan as they all played along with the game. He smiled at Elizabeth’s blunder and paid her a visit the next morning. Elizabeth said she was mortified and wanted to know if he was upset.

When Calls The Heart’s Lucas assured his sweetheart he was not and asked if Elizabeth had a chance to speak with Nathan about it. She said she went by the jail, and it was awkward. Bashfully, Elizabeth Thornton admitted Nathan told her again that he loved her. Lucas Bouchard seemed a bit annoyed as he asked her what she said back to him.

Lucas appeared to change his demeanor after Elizabeth Thornton told him she said nothing to Nathan. She just left. Team Lucas fans wonder why she has never rejected Nathan’s expressions of love. Hearties think she should let Nathan know she has no feelings for him, rather than running away. Lucas Bouchard abruptly left, making fans wonder if he’s stepping out of the race for Elizabeth’s heart. Will she be able to overcome Nathan’s indirect part in her husband’s untimely demise on Hallmark Channel’s When Calls The Heart?

Follow Soap Dirt for all the When Calls The Heart news