Bachelor in Paradise drama is already heating up between Blake Horstmann and Caelynn Miller-Keyes. But it started before the two even stepped on the beach. Blake and Caelynn were reportedly seeing one another about a week before the show started. According to Caelynn, Blake slept with Kristina Schulman the night before he slept with her. Then, he apparently ghosted Caelynn before BIP began filming. But Blake released some telling text messages that flip the script and portray Caelynn as the one looking for something casual. Which one is telling the truth?
Bachelor in Paradise: The Blake Horstmann & Caelynn Miller-Keyes Drama
Blake Horstmann talked to Caelynn Miller-Keyes before arriving to shoot Bachelor in Paradise. Yet, it seems the two were doing more than that. Because she told everyone on the beach they slept together at Stagecoach in April. The trouble started after she found out he shagged Kristina Schulman just 24 hours before that.
Caelynn Miller-Keyes claims that she tried to talk to him and Blake ghosted her. She hadn’t seen him again until she arrived on BIP. There, she told her version of the story to just about anyone who was in her general vicinity. But Blake shared his own side of what happened with the entire world through social media about his Bachelor in Paradise co-star.
Blake Horstmann Posts Texts With Caelynn Miller-Keyes
In a desperate move to prove to Bachelor Nation that he was not the one in the wrong, Blake Horstmann shared texts from Caelynn from the weekend everything went down. From the proof he posted to Instagram, it appears that Caelynn was the one looking for a casual hook up. “Let’s just have a good time man,” she tells him in one of the many messages.
Blake originally just wanted to cuddle with no sexual activities, but Caelynn appears to pressure him into agreeing to it. “If I come over it’s strictly for sex” she wrote. She made it seem like she didn’t want any strings attached. That’s drastically different than what she said about him being a total tool on Bachelor in Paradise.
Blake Apologizes For Causing Caelynn Trouble on BIP
Several hours after posting the text messages, Blake Horstmann deleted the post and explained why in a series of Instagram stories. “Releasing the text messages was the last thing I wanted to do,” an emotional Blake said in the videos. He said he felt he had no choice but to show his proof. He also said he hopes Caelynn can forgive him at some point.
Blake Horstmann appeared to be very remorseful for sharing his truth. Later, he apologized to Caelynn Miller-Keyes multiple times in the explanation. Keep watching BIP to find out if they put the past behind them!
Follow Soap Dirt for the latest Bachelor in Paradise news!