90 Day Fiance: The Other Way’s Corey Rathgeber seems to be backtracking on his split with Evelin Villegas. Despite the cheating reveals seen on the season, it seems he just can’t quit her. While Evelin’s in Ecuador (reportedly with Laura Jallali), her ex Corey’s in Scottsdale, Arizona with David Toborowsky and Annie Suwan. But some social media clues point to yet another reunion between this on-again off-again couple coming soon. Will Corey Rathgeber cave and go crawling back to Evelin Villegas?
90 Day Fiance: The Other Way Tell All Crushed Corey Rathgeber
According to a leaker in production that brings tidbits to Soap Dirt, the recently filmed (but not yet aired) Tell All hit Corey Rathgeber hard. Although Evelin Villegas admitting to cheating with her ex, there’s more to it. Corey later shielded Evelin from criticism by insisting they were on a break when he had previously said they weren’t. But 90 Day Fiance fans aren’t having it and have raged at the Ecuadorian for cheating on the good-boy Mormon from Washington.
But at the 90 Day Fiance: The Other Way Tell All, our leaker told us that cast members, including Corey Rathgeber, had to sign a “mental health waiver” and they had a shrink on-hand. That’s because TLC had a bombshell to drop on Corey about Evelin’s extracurricular activities. Reportedly, they played an unaired clip featuring Evelin Villegas and the guy she cheated with, blindsiding Corey.
Split Came After Tell All Clip Showed More Info On Evelin’s Cheating
Later, 90 Day Fiance: The Other Way‘s Corey Rathgeber reportedly walked off set and went to sob with the therapist because it hit him so hard. And by having him sign the waiver first, it sure looks like TLC knew they’d get that reaction. But then, not long after that filmed, Corey launched a blindside of his own.
On his birthday, Corey Rathgeber broke up with Evelin Villegas and blocked her across his social channels. She confirmed the split in a series of videos from her partying and smack talking saying that before the break-up she was stuck Netflix and chilling with Corey. But now, she could party. Evelin also asked 90 Day Fiance followers to tell Corey happy birthday since he’d blocked her.
Corey Takes Refuge With Other 90 Day Fiance Cast Members
As for Corey, he kept it classy by not acknowledging the drunken rants and said that what’s happening is “personal and strictly” between them. He acknowledged that fans have questions, but wouldn’t answer them. However, he did respond personally to personal birthday well-wishes on his IG. Then, he went to cry things out with two other 90 Day Fiance alumns – Annie and David Toborowsky.
Also there was 90 Day Fiance: Before the 90 Days Benjamin Taylor. Sources at the meet and greet report that Corey Rathgeber seemed sad. Benjamin posted some sweet comments about Corey being a nice guy and single. But, how long will he be on his own? Because came next points to an opening for a reunion… And fans won’t like this at all because many don’t think Evelin’s worthy of him.
90 Day Fiance: The Other Way – Corey Lays Groundwork for Evelin Reunion?
The notice that Evelin Villegas got that she’d been dumped was Corey Rathgeber unfollowing and blocking her on Instagram. That’s when she went on her party binge. But now, is Corey wiping away his tears and looking for a reunion? After all, he and Evelin have split before and gotten back together. And even with this recent break-up, he kept defending her to fans. Recent pictures also show that he still wears his commitment ring.
Now, the 90 Day Fiance: The Other Way cast member has unblocked and refollowed Evelin Villegas. That seems to be him softening his attitude on the split. Because not only did he refollow Evelin, but he’s hitting like on her recent posts. So, for those Team Corey fans hoping he’d learned his lesson, don’t hold your breath. It looks like this thing might be resparking. Watch to see if Corey Rathgeber gets back with Evelin Villegas…
Watch TLC for new episodes and hit us back at Soap Dirt for more of your hot 90 Day Fiance info and spoilers.